Starter for Ten At Bristol Old Vic

Following a wildly successful original run in March 2024, Antic Productions’ Starter for Ten is once more gracing the famous main stage of Bristol Old Vic.

Readers of fiction tend to behold with an experienced skepticism any filmic or theatrical adaptation of beloved work (I was once inadvertently subjected to thirty seconds of Fry & Laurie’s ‘take’ on the imperishable work of PG Wodehouse, and sunk into a kind of black lethargy for several months).

Admirers of David Nicholls’ 2003 novel need not fret. Starter for Ten wins you over in the opening score. And it does so with the most basic and strangely under-discussed feature of theatre: the sheer quality of the work. In the cultural milieu of a press night, so much time is dedicated to the subtext and subtleties of a piece, that we can sometimes miss the forest for the trees. When busily stroking our chins and trying to decode what a play is saying, we risk missing the beauty of the voice that is saying it. Starter for Ten is, before it is anything else, an extremely well executed piece of theatre.

The fundamental danger with this production was the very same that threatened the Billy Elliot musical. That is to say, ensconcing social realism and class consciousness into the often quite jangly context of musical theatre. In a strange sort of a way, the device of University Challenge itself I think helps to ease this potential disharmony. In marrying the innately frivolous tone of television quizzes with the roaring head of class inequity - the university system - University Challenge serves as an ideal bridge between form and theme.

Attendees of the March 2024 run will be greeted with several familiar faces. Adam Bregman reprises his role as Brian Jackson, a working-class kid from Southend-on-Sea who arrives at Bristol University and is almost at once dazzled and led wayward by the privilege around him. Bregman portrays exactly the dis-ease of first encountering individuals with a cultural capital and social fluency you thought only existed on tele. That Brian’s integrity buckles under the practiced charm of minor aristocracy is no surprise at all. Bregman’s performance is fantastic.

Responsible for the weakening and corruption of our working class hero is Alice Harbinson, played by the spectacular debutant Imogen Craig. I did check about forty-five times to ensure that I’ve got that right, because this was a debut in name only. Craig plays excellently the almost cartoonishly effeminate and irreproachable Alice, who in a deeply comic sense seems to exist as Brian Jackson’s nightmare of the most intimidating possible woman: wealthy, smart and sexy. The slightly unreal quality of Alice roots this production firmly in the working class perspective of Brian, to whom Alice appears as something almost not-human, as something you might see on the tele.

From a strong field, I felt the greatest performance belonged to Will Jennings, who plays team captain Patrick Watts. Jennings’ singing voice is unbelievable, and his comic physicality and overall presence stole my attention whenever he was on stage. Miracle Chance reprises her role as medical student Lucy, who is somehow even more bookish than the rest of the team. Chance is a brilliant comic actor and singer, who appears from behind her enormous rucksack to deliver wonderfully scathing rebukes of her teammates.

Outside of the quiz team, Asha Parker-Wallace plays Rebecca, who readers will remember as the Scottish socialist that our idiot protagonist Brian is too busy to notice is clearly the girl for him. Parker-Wallace is excellent, by turns teasing and uplifting Brian with a clearly natural charisma and a fantastic singing voice.

Mel Giedroyc returns as Irene Jackson, Brian’s mum, and multi-roles as Julia Bland. The apparent ease with which Giedroyc flits between these two incredibly different roles is a pleasure to see. Giedroyc is far and away the most accomplished actor on stage, having worked on several multi-award winning shows in television and theatre. Whilst in a supporting role on this occasion, Giedroyc’s presence and professionalism elevates the entire production noticeably.

Stephen Ashfield joins the cast as Bamber Gascoigne and Brian’s Dad. Ashfield is exceptional - capturing so well the charm and charisma of the late Gascoigne, whilst again having to strike a very different and more emotive tone as Brian’s Dad. Christian Maynard plays Spencer, Brian’s friend from back home who dramaturgically serves as his anchor and point of contrast against his new posh love interest. Maynard’s muscular performance aids the show tremendously. As Dr. Bowman, Rachel John offers an energetic and comic performance as a very fed-up tutor.

Starter for Ten is an excellent production: incisive about class and funny about cleverness. Two hours fly by in a reverie of exceptional music and brain-scrambling conundrums.

Tickets are available here: https://bristololdvic.org.uk/whats-on/starter-for-ten


Image credit: Bristol Old Vic

Theatre Criticism